- AutorIn
- Susanne Müller
- Titel
- Individuals’ Resonance with Nature as a Deep Leverage Point for Sustainability Transformations: Weaving Sustainability Science, Psychology, Psychotherapy, and Transdisciplinary Epistemologies
- Zitierfähige Url:
- https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:14-qucosa2-1068225
- Datum der Einreichung
- 25.11.2025
- Datum der Verteidigung
- 26.08.2026
- Abstract (EN)
- Humanity’s response to the social–ecological crises has so far remained fragmented and hesitant. Many current approaches focus narrowly on adapting to the existing order or mitigating its most immediate consequences. In contrast, a profound sustainability transformation requires addressing the underlying causes of these crises. According to numerous scholars and Indigenous traditions, these causes lie in modern humanity’s alienated relationship with nature. Consequently, sustainability science has increasingly called for a relational turn aimed at reconnecting humans with nature. In this context, Hartmut Rosa’s theory of resonance, together with the deduced concept of human–nature resonance, has gained attention for its integrative potential across systems, transformation, and target knowledge. Yet despite their theoretical richness, these approaches still lack an empirical operationalization of how resonance with nature can, in practice, be cultivated and sustained. Against this background, this dissertation aims to illuminate the active fostering of resonance with nature. Drawing on the extensive knowledge within psychology and psychotherapy regarding the shaping and transformation of individual mindsets, it focuses on individual actors as the primary site of investigation, with the intention of ultimately upscaling these insights toward broader societal transformation. In doing so, the work integrates psychological and psychotherapeutic perspectives into the process of individuals fostering resonance with nature. Moreover, acknowledging the ontological and epistemological limitations within both psychology and sustainability science, the work is enriched through transdisciplinary epistemologies that incorporate Indigenous ontologies, embodied self experience, and artistic practice. Across Publications 1, 2, and 3, I address three research gaps and corresponding sub aims of the overarching research goal, employing distinct theoretical and methodological approaches. First, a conceptual and interdisciplinary paper lays the groundwork for understanding how individuals can foster resonance with nature. This contribution engages deeply with a triad of concepts: Indigenous ontologies, spirituality and transpersonal psychology, and mindfulness. These relational perspectives have received increasing attention for their potential to advance sustainability transformations and were therefore used to further develop resonance theory and the concept of human–nature resonance. In addition, following Hartmut Rosa’s emphasis on rituals as means of fostering resonance, the role of rituals in sustainability contexts was examined. The resulting conceptualization of individuals resonating with nature includes the following dimensions: openness, granting nature the value of Unverfügbarkeit (English: inaccessibility), being affected by nature, responding, and mutual transformation. Aiming to move beyond a purely theoretical contribution, and drawing on my own transdisciplinary self experience, a practical framework in the form of a ritual intervention was outlined. To enliven the reading experience and add an affective dimension, the text was complemented with a graphical abstract and small icons, each representing one resonance dimension and made available as open access materials. Second, building on these conceptual foundations, a five week feasibility panel study was conducted to empirically examine the concept of individual human–nature resonance. The study employed a psychological experimental design with a control group, using the proposed urban ritual as the intervention framework. Each resonance dimension was operationalized through specific tools and nurturing exercises, while a set of psychological scales was applied to assess potential changes. As a feasibility study with a limited sample size, the results did not yield statistical significance. Nevertheless, participants in the ritual condition exhibited increased pro environmental behavior both immediately after the study and again five months later. Additional findings concerning health, social connectedness, and emotional self regulation also suggest beneficial effects of the intervention, which warrant further examination in future trials. When doing so, it is recommended paying greater attention to the societal contexts in which individuals are embedded, as these conditions may substantially constrain their resonance dispositions. Third, in response to the societal obstacles encountered in the feasibility study, it was sought to address and alleviate these barriers. Echoing scholarly calls to reassess prevailing social norms and goals in light of relational ontologies, I argue that the dominant concept of resilience may constitute an inner sustainability impediment that limits deeper resonance with nature. As an alternative, I propose vulnerability as a critical mode of relation. Rather than prescribing a fixed method, it was aimed to open a reflective and trustful space for rethinking current societal values and norms. To this end, I first contextualized resilience to engage the reader cognitively within a theoretical framework, then contrasted its limited compatibility with nature connectedness while elaborating how vulnerability fosters this bond. Finally, I drew on transdisciplinary insights from art to exemplify these arguments in a more affective and epistemologically diverse way, thereby broadening dominant ontological perspectives. Recognizing that an author’s positionality inevitably shapes how research gaps are addressed, after the publications I reflect on the suitability of my approaches. In this respect, I also consider the original inherent perspective of the dissertation on the potential formulation of transformation knowledge. I then provide a synthesis of the dissertation that simultaneously acknowledges its limitations. Using the letters of the verb ‘decide’, six directions are proposed for advancing the topic of individuals resonating with nature so that it may unfold its potential as a deep leverage point for sustainability transformations. In this regard, beyond researching the capability to decide (‘D’), I emphasize the importance of experience and haptics in human life (‘E’), the value of congruence both within ourselves as transformative researchers and within society at large (‘C’), as well as the partial invisibility of our research objects (‘I’). Finally, the necessity of disciplinary diversity (‘D’) and epistemic plurality (‘E’) are highlighted to further cultivate resonant relationships in modern societies. I conclude with a reflective invitation to the reader. In a well known performance, the artist Julia Engelmann asked her audience what stories they would wish to tell when looking back on their lives. Inspired by this idea and speaking as a transformative researcher, readers are invited to consider how they might wish to remember the present moment we are all shaping now.
- Verweis
- Opening the human spirit to sustainability transformation: the potential for individual human–nature resonance and integrative rituals
DOI: 10.1007/s11625-023-01360-x - Exploring the fosterage of individuals’ resonances with nature through a 5-week-long ritual: findings, limits and outlook of a feasibility study for sustainability transformations
DOI: 10.1007/s43621-025-01399-z - Let’s talk about vulnerability: a critical plea for relationality with nature, rethinking resilience and transdisciplinary knowledge in sustainability transformations
DOI: 10.31235/osf.io/b7kwh_v1 - Forschungsdatenverweis
- Survey data of a first feasibility study to foster urban residents' resonances with nature through rituals
Link: https://zenodo.org/records/14734157 - Freie Schlagwörter (DE)
- Mensch-Natur-Beziehungen, Liebe, relationale Ontologien, transdisziplinäre Epistemologien, Resonanz
- Klassifikation (DDC)
- 304
- Klassifikation (RVK)
- AR 14300
- GutachterIn
- Prof. Dr. Nicole Raschke
- Prof. Dr. Andra-Ioana Horcea-Milcu
- Prof. Dr. Riklef Rambow
- Den akademischen Grad verleihende / prüfende Institution
- Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden
- Förder- / Projektangaben
- Leibniz-Gemeinschaft Leibniz-Wettbewerb
Urbane Mensch-Natur Resonanz für eine Nachhaltigkeitstransformation
(URBNANCE)
ID: J76/2019 - Version / Begutachtungsstatus
- publizierte Version / Verlagsversion
- URN Qucosa
- urn:nbn:de:bsz:14-qucosa2-1068225
- Veröffentlichungsdatum Qucosa
- 15.09.2026
- Dokumenttyp
- Dissertation
- Sprache des Dokumentes
- Englisch
- Lizenz / Rechtehinweis
CC BY-NC-ND 4.0- Inhaltsverzeichnis
Table of Contents Abstract 7 List of Figures 11 List of Tables 12 Abbreviations 13 1. Introduction 14 1.1 Background and Research Relevance 14 1.2 Research Gaps and Questions 17 1.2.1 Gap 1: A Missing Theoretical Framework for Individuals’ Integrative Reconnection with Nature 17 1.2.2 Gap 2: No Empirical Concept for Overcoming the Mind-Action Gap 18 1.2.3 Gap 3: How to Scale Up Individuals’ Responsive Relationships to Society? 18 1.3 Aims, Institutional Embeddedness of the Dissertation, and Structure 19 2. Theoretical Background 22 2.1 Towards Relational Ontologies for Sustainability Transformations 22 2.2 Resonance Theory and Human-Nature Resonance 22 2.3 Methods to Strengthen the Human-Nature Bond 23 2.4 The Role of Transdisciplinary Epistemologies for Sustainability Transformations 24 2.5 How to Upscale Individual Transformations 24 3. Publications 26 3.1 Publication 1: Opening the Human Spirit to Sustainability Transformation: The Potential for Individual Human–Nature Resonance and Integrative Rituals 27 3.2 Publication 2: Exploring the Fosterage of Individuals’ Resonances with Nature through a 5-Week-Long Ritual: Findings, Limits, and Outlook of a Feasibility Study for Sustainability Transformations 59 3.3 Publication 3: Let’s Talk about Vulnerability: A Critical Plea for Relationality with Nature, Rethinking Resilience and Transdisciplinary Knowledge in Sustainability Transformations [preprint] 98 4. Reflecting Upon the Publications 123 4.1 Publication 1 123 4.1.1 Theoretical Approach 123 4.1.2 Methodology 124 4.1.3 Overall Evaluation of Addressing Research Gap 1 124 4.2 Publication 2 125 4.2.1 Theoretical Approach 125 4.2.2 Methodology 125 4.2.3 Overall Evaluation of Addressing Research Gap 2 126 4.3 Publication 3 127 4.3.1 Theoretical Approach 127 4.3.2 Methodology 129 4.3.3 Overall Evaluation of Addressing Research Gap 3 129 5. Synthesis and Recommended Directions Forward 131 D—Deciding 132 E—Experiences and Haptics 133 C—Congruency 135 I—Invisibility 135 D—Disciplinary Diversity 137 E—Epistemic Plurality 138 6. Conclusion 140 Literature 142 Appendix 150